Election News

New York Congressional Map Ruled Invalid by State's Highest Court

The New York Court of Appeals has sided with lower courts, ruling the state's previously-enacted congressional map is invalid. The redistricted State Senate map was also thrown out.

The court said new maps need to be redrawn for this year's elections, likely necessitating the move of primaries for these offices to August. 

The state's current U.S. House delegation is comprised of 19 Democrats and 8 Republicans. The invalidated map would have given Democrats up to three additional seats in the November elections, with Republicans losing four. The state is losing a seat based on 2020 Census results. 

As the redrawn map will likely be less advantageous to Democrats, the party is now in an even more precarious position with regards to holding the House after the midterm elections.

Redistricting Update: Florida, Kansas, Missouri, New Hampshire, New York

UPDATE: Shortly after this article was published, the New York State Court of Appeals ruled that the congressional map must be redrawn. It also tossed the State Senate map and noted that the primary for these offices will likely need to move to August.

==

On Tuesday, the New York State Court of Appeals - the state's highest court - held a hearing on the state's previously-enacted congressional map. The map, which strongly favored Democrats, had been ruled unconstitutional by two lower courts earlier this month. A ruling is expected quickly. The state's primary is scheduled for June 28. (Full primary calendar >>)

On Monday, a Kansas court invalidated that state's congressional map. The decision will be appealed to the State Supreme Court. The primary is August 2.

These district shapes were removed from the 2022 House Interactive map. Two other states, Missouri (August 2 primary) and New Hampshire (September 13) have not yet completed redistricting.

There has been little movement in Missouri, where the two legislative branches - both controlled by Republicans - have been unable to agree on a map. Lawsuits have been filed about the lack of a map in both state and federal court.

In New Hampshire, a proposed map was introduced this week by GOP legislators after Gov. Chris Sununu (R) said he would veto the prior map sent to his desk. From a partisan perspective, the new map is little changed from the old one. It would make District 1 more favorable for a GOP pick-up, while making it more likely Democrats hold District 2. In a statement, Sununu gave the new map a thumbs down; he favors two competitive districts in keeping with the 'purple' lean of the state. 

Consensus Map

Last Friday, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) signed into law the state's new congressional map. Litigation is underway regarding the map, which strongly favors Republicans. Initial ratings for the state's 28 districts have been added to the 2022 Consensus map

40 districts, across the four states discussed above, remain incomplete. 

Kansas Congressional Map Invalidated

A Kansas judge has thrown out the state's enacted congressional map, calling it an "intentional, effective pro-Republican gerrymander that systematically dilutes the votes of Democratic Kansans." Per Politico, "it was the first time a court has declared that the Kansas Constitution prohibits political gerrymandering." 

The prior map became law in February when the Republican-controlled Legislature overrode the veto of Democratic Gov. Laura Kelly.

The ruling is expected to be appealed to the Kansas Supreme Court. June 1 is the filing deadline for the state's August 2 primary.

 

Florida Legislature Passes DeSantis Redistricting Plan; Shapes Added to Interactive Map

The Florida Legislature passed a redistricting plan Thursday, sending it to Gov. Ron DeSantis (R). As the map originated from the governor's office, his signature would seem to be a foregone conclusion. As such, the new shapes have been added to the 2022 House Interactive Map.  

The new map is quite favorable to Republicans, with the party expected to gain up to four seats in this fall's midterm elections. In that scenario, Democrats would lose three, as the state gained a district after the 2020 Census.

The graphic below compares the two maps. The new map is colored based on the spread between Joe Biden and Donald Trump in 2020, as calculated by Matthew Isbell, publisher of The MCIMAPS Report. That analysis shows 18 seats where Trump won by >5%. Districts 15 and 27, the only two seats decided by <5%, are both held by Republicans. 

The map effectively eliminates the current District 5, which stretches across the northern tier of the state. It was shaped that way after court-ordered redistricting prior to the 2016 election and was intended to let Black voters elect a representative of their choice. Democrat Al Lawson is now in his third term there. The map also splits up Black voters around the Orlando area, likely eliminating a Democratic-held district there. (Current FL-10 Rep. Val Demings is running for the Democratic nomination for U.S. Senate). 

Litigation is expected to explore whether the new plan violates the state's Fair Districts Amendments or the federal Voting Rights Act. 

Live Results: California Assembly District 17 Special Election

We're tracking one legislative special election this week.

California State Assembly District 17

Democrats hold 57 of 80 seats in the California Assembly. There are 19 Republicans and one independent. Members serve two year terms. The next regularly scheduled elections are in November. Those will be contested under redistricted boundaries.

Three seats are open, all were previously held by Democrats. Vacancies in Districts 62 and 80 held primaries on April 5. Those general elections will be June 7, the same date as the statewide primary.

District 17 is located in San Francisco. The seat became vacant when Democrat David Chiu was sworn in as San Francisco City Attorney in November. 

No Republican has contested this districts since 2016. There were four Democrats on the February 15 primary ballot; none received a majority of the vote. The top two finishers - Matt Haney (36.4% of the vote) and David Campos (35.7%) - were separated by just over 700 votes. Affordable housing is a key issue in the race.

Polls close at 11:00 PM Eastern Time.

Upcoming

No elections (that we cover) next week. May is the third busiest month for statewide primaries on the 2022 calendar.

  • May 3
    • Indiana Primary
    • Ohio Primary
    • Georgia State House District 45 Runoff
    • Michigan State House Districts 15, 36, 43, and 74 Special Elections
  • May 7
    • Lubbock, Texas Mayoral Election
      • Runoff, if necessary, on May 24
    • Texas State House District 147 Special Election
  • May 10
    • Nebraska Primary
    • West Virginia Primary
    • Newark, NJ Mayoral Election
  • May 17
    • Idaho Primary
    • Kentucky Primary
    • North Carolina Primary
      • Runoffs, where necessary, on July 26
    • Oregon Primary
    • Pennsylvania Primary
    • Charlotte and Greensboro, NC Mayoral Primaries
    • Lexington and Louisville, KY Mayoral Primaries
    • Oregon State Senate Senate District 18 Special Primary
    • Pennsylvania State House District 5 Special Election
    • South Carolina State House District 97 Special Election
  • May 24
    • Alabama Primary
      • Runoffs, where necessary, on July 26
    • Arkansas Primary
      • Runoffs, where necessary, on June 21
    • Georgia Primary
      • Runoffs, where necessary, on June 21
    • Texas Primary Runoffs
    • Minnesota Congressional District 1 Special Primary
    • South Carolina State House District 18 Special Election

Florida Legislature to Defer to DeSantis on Congressional Redistricting

In a joint statement issued Monday, Republican leaders of both branches of the Florida Legislature announced they will defer to Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) on congressional redistricting. The Legislature is awaiting a map acceptable to the governor, which they will evaluate and presumably pass during the upcoming April 19-22 special session.

DeSantis had previously vetoed a plan passed by the Legislature. While the map was favorable to Republicans, it did not go far enough in meeting the governor's demand to make District 5 more compact.

In its current format, District 5 stretches across the northern tier of the state. It was shaped that way after court-ordered redistricting prior to the 2016 election and is intended to let Black voters elect a representative of their choice. Democrat Al Lawson is now in his third term there.

After a new map is enacted, a court battle is expected over whether it meets the standards of the Fair Districts Amendments to the State Constitution, approved by voters in 2010.  

Overview and Live Results: New York Assembly District 20 Special Election

This week, we have an unusual Thursday special election to to fill a legislative vacancy.

New York State Assembly District 20

Democrats hold a large majority in the New York State Assembly. The party controls 106 seats, alongside 42 Republicans and one Independence Party member.

Members serve two-year terms. The next regularly scheduled elections will be in November. These will be contested using redistricted boundaries. Note that these new districts are being challenged in court. A judge ruled the maps unconstitutional on March 31. That decision has been stayed by a higher court while the appeal proceeds.

District 20 borders the New York City borough of Queens in southwestern Long Island. Republican Melissa Miller resigned in February after being appointed to the Hempstead town board. She won her third term by 59% to 41% in 2020.

Miller's prior wins were by single digit margins, including in 2016, when she flipped the district from Democratic control. It is unclear if this electoral history means we'll see a close special election or if the district has moved too far to the right for Democrats to compete.

There are two candidates on the ballot. Polls close at 9:00 PM Eastern Time.

Ohio Republican Rep. Bob Gibbs Announces Retirement

Citing an "irresponsible" redistricting process, six-term Ohio Republican Rep. Bob Gibbs (OH-07) announced his retirement Wednesday. Gibbs will serve through the end of this Congress.

In his statement, Gibbs expressed frustration that the new congressional map was finalized - and perhaps only in effect for 2022 - just a week prior to the start of early voting, particularly since the new 7th district only contains about 10% population overlap with the existing 7th. (Gibbs isn't the only member seeing large shifts, some of which is driven by the fact that Ohio is losing a district.)

Per Cleveland.com, Gibbs was also facing some primary challengers "including Max Miller, a well-funded former White House aide to [and endorsed by] ex-President Donald Trump." 

Early voting for the May 3 primary began on Monday. Due to ongoing redistricting litigation around the state legislative maps, the primary for those elections will be conducted at a later date.

48 current members, including 30 Democrats and 18 Republicans, have announced they are retiring or seeking another office.

Overview and Live Results: California Congressional District 22, Other Special Elections

This week, we're tracking a number of special elections, highlighted by the all-party primary for a vacant congressional district in California. There are legislative races in California, Georgia, and Pennsylvania. On the municipal front, voters in Milwaukee will elect a mayor.

Congressional Special Primary Election

California District 22

This seat has been open since the start of the 117th Congress in January. Republican Devin Nunes vacated the seat to lead Trump Media & Technology Group. 

In California, all candidates appear on a single primary ballot. In regular elections, the top two advance to the general election. This is also the case in special elections, unless one candidate gets a majority of the primary vote. In that case, they are elected. If a special general election is needed, that will take place on June 7, the same date as the statewide primary. 

There are four Republicans and two Democrats on the primary ballot. The frontrunner appears to be Republican Connie Conway, a former member of the State Assembly. Polls close at 11:00 PM Eastern Time.

There's a good chance that the winner of the special election will only serve in Congress until the end of the year. California is losing a district, and the current District 22 is essentially being eliminated, its current borders largely folded into the new Districts 5, 20 and 21. 

Three participants in Tuesday's election - two Republicans and one Democrat - have entered the June 7 primary in the new District 21. Democrat Jim Costa (current CA-16) is running as the incumbent. While it is likely that one of the special election Republicans will advance with Costa, the district has been made safer for Democrats in redistricting.

The other three entrants in the special election - including Conway, the frontrunner - did not file for any seats in the regular 2022 election.

State Legislative Special General Elections

Georgia State House District 45

Republicans hold a 102-77 edge over Democrats in the Georgia State House. Members serve two year terms; the next regular elections are in November. These will be contested using redistricted boundaries.

District 45 is located in Atlanta's northern suburbs. Republican Matt Dollar resigned in February to take another position. Dollar was unopposed when first elected in 2012 and didn't face a challenger until 2018. That year, he won by nearly 20% over his Democratic foe; that gap narrowed to 10 points in 2020. 

Of Tuesday's seven State House special elections and primaries, this one is likely to be the most competitive from a party control perspective.

In Georgia, special elections include all candidates from all parties. In this race, there are three Republicans and one Democrat. If no candidate gets a majority of the vote, the top two finishers will meet in a May 3 runoff.

Polls close at 7:00 PM Eastern Time.

Pennsylvania State House Districts 19, 24, and 116

Republicans hold 112 seats in the 203-member Pennsylvania State House. There are 88 Democrats. Members serve two year terms; the next regular elections are in November. These will be contested using redistricted boundaries.

Tuesday's elections will fill the chamber's three vacancies. Nominees were chosen directly by the political parties. Polls close at 8:00 PM Eastern Time.

District 19: This Pittsburgh-area district has not been contested by Republicans over the last decade. That will continue with this special election; Democrat Aerion Abney is unopposed on the ballot. The prior officeholder, Democrat Jake Wheatley Jr. resigned in January to become Chief of Staff to Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey. 

District 24: Located just east of District 19, the prior incumbent, Ed Gainey was elected Mayor of Pittsburgh this past November. Although Republicans haven't contested this district over the past decade, they do have a candidate in the special election. Perhaps reflecting a very thin bench for the party in this part of the state, that nominee, Todd Koger, ran for this seat as a Democrat in both 2016 and 2018. The Democratic nominee is Martell Covington.

District 116: This district sits west of Wilkes-Barre. It was last represented by Republican Tarah Toohil. She resigned at the end of 2021 after being elected as a judge on the Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas. Toohil last won reelection by a 72% to 28% margin over her Democratic challenger in 2020. There are three candidates on the ballot.

State Legislative Special Primary Elections

California Assembly Districts 11, 62, and 80

The lower legislative chamber in California is known as the State Assembly. Democrats hold 56 of the 80 seats. There are 19 Republicans and one independent. Members serve two year terms; the next regular elections are in November. These will be contested using redistricted boundaries.

Tuesday's all-party primaries will start the process of filling three of four vacancies. If a candidate receives a majority of the vote, they are elected. Otherwise, the top two finishers advance to the June 7 general election. Polls close at 11:00 PM Eastern Time.

District 11: Located between San Francisco and Sacramento, this district was represented over the past decade by Democrat Jim Frazier. He resigned December 31. Frazier was reelected by a 65% to 35% margin in 2020. The only candidate on the ballot is Democrat Lori Wilson. Republican Erik Elness has been certified as a write-in candidate. 

District 62: This coastal Southern California district includes Inglewood and Los Angeles International Airport. Democrat Autumn Burke resigned earlier this year. She had been first elected in 2014. In 2020, she was reelected with 81% of the vote. Four Democrats are on the primary ballot. 

District 80: This district runs from the Mexico border to San Diego. Democrat Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher resigned in January. She was first elected in 2013. In 2020, she was reelected with 72% of the vote. There are two Democrats and one Republican on the ballot. While one of the Democrats is expected to prevail, this race has drawn some outsized interest.

Mayoral Special General Election

Milwaukee

Milwaukee is the 31st largest city in the United States,1 1City rankings are based on July 1, 2020 Census Bureau population estimates. They are for the city itself, not the associated metropolitan area. with a population of just over 577,000. 

The acting mayor is Democrat Cavalier Johnson, who also serves as the City's Common Council President. Johnson became acting mayor when five-term incumbent Tom Barrett resigned in December after being unanimously confirmed as the new U.S. Ambassador to Luxembourg. 

Johnson finished first in the February 15 nonpartisan primary with 42% of the vote. In second place was former Alderman Bob Donovan, who previously ran for mayor in 2016. According to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, "The candidates have offered voters a juxtaposition of a 35-year-old Democratic north side alderman who has moved up quickly at City Hall since his first election win in 2016 and a 65-year-old conservative former council member who spent 20 years representing a south side district before retiring in 2020."

The winner of this election will complete Barrett's term, which ends in 2024. Polls close at 9:00 PM Eastern Time.

Upcoming

  • April 7
    • New York State Assembly District 20 Special Election
  • April 19
    • California State Assembly District 17 Special Election
  • May 3
    • Indiana Primary
    • Ohio Primary
    • Michigan State House Districts 15, 36, 43, and 74 Special Elections
  • May 7
    • Lubbock, Texas Mayoral Election
    • Texas State House District 147 Special Election
  • May 10
    • Nebraska Primary
    • West Virginia Primary
    • Newark, NJ Mayoral Election
  • May 17
    • Idaho Primary
    • Kentucky Primary
    • North Carolina Primary
      • Runoffs, where necessary, on July 26
    • Oregon Primary
    • Pennsylvania Primary
    • Charlotte and Greensboro, NC Mayoral Primaries
    • Lexington and Louisville, KY Mayoral Primaries
    • Oregon State Senate Senate District 18 Special Primary
    • Pennsylvania State House District 5 Special Election
    • South Carolina State House District 97 Special Election

Michigan Republican Rep. Fred Upton to Retire

Michigan Rep. Fred Upton (MI-06) announced Tuesday that he won't seek reelection this year. Now serving his 18th term, Upton is third in House Republican seniority.

Upton was one of 10 House Republicans that voted to impeach Donald Trump last January. He is the fourth of those to retire; most of the others are facing a Trump-endorsed primary challenger.

In addition to running afoul of the former president, Upton was also facing an intraparty primary against Rep. Bill Huizenga (MI-02). With Michigan losing a seat this year, the two incumbents were redistricted together into the new 4th district. The consensus rating for that district in this year's midterms is Likely Republican.

47 current House members - including 30 Democrats and 17 Republicans - have said they are retiring or running for another office this year.