Proposed Constitutional Amendment: Apportionment Based on Citizenship

As reported by GovTrack, Iowa Republican Rep. Steve King has introduced a Joint Resolution for a proposed constitutional amendment that would apportion congressional districts based on the number of U.S. citizens in each state. Currently, this apportionment is determined by the number of residents* of each state, as calculated in each Census.

This is not the first time such an amendment has been proposed. While it is highly unlikely that the current proposal will get anywhere, we were curious how the electoral map would shift if it was only based on citizens.**  

This report estimates the number of U.S. citizens in each state as of 2013, and uses those totals to calculate the number of congressional districts for each state. Somewhat surprisingly, only 11 states would be impacted. The big loser would be California, which would see 4 of its 55 electoral votes trimmed away. No other state was impacted by more than one electoral vote. FL, NY and TX would lose one each, while seven states (LA, MO, MT, NC, OH, OK, VA) would gain one.  

In terms of states won in the 2016 election, Donald Trump would have won 4 additional electoral votes, giving him 310. Faithless Electors were excluded.  

* Also included are overseas military and civilian federal employee population and their dependents living with them. In most states, this is well under 1% of the resident population.

** Each state receives electoral votes equal to its congressional delegation. That includes two U.S. Senators and one for each congressional district. Changing how congressional districts are allocated would therefore change the distribution of electoral votes. 

comments powered by Disqus

Headlines

Overview & Live Results: Primary Day in Georgia, Alabama, and Arkansas; Runoff Elections in Texas

The value of an endorsement from Donald Trump will be put to the test in a number of nominating contests.

Live Results: Minnesota Congressional District Special Primary Election

The district has been vacant since the February death of Republican Jim Hagedorn. Special general election will be August 9.

Live Results: State House Special Elections in New York and South Carolina

There is one vacancy in each state that will be filled Tuesday

New York Court Finalizes Congressional Map; Shapes Added to Interactive Map

The map replaces one ruled a Democratic gerrymander by this same court in late March

Florida Court of Appeals Reinstates Previously Enacted Redistricting Map

Further litigation, in front of the Florida Supreme Court, is likely